Bear Hunting's Tug of War
An Editorial - by Steve Brandle
The game of “tug of war” is a simple concept. Two teams
grab different ends of a rope and try to pull each other
across a line in the dirt. No complicated rules or
strategy to sort out, just the common goal of teamwork to
win the game. Hunters in Michigan and the world have been
in a tug of war with the animal rights / anti-hunter
groups for years. The battle has reached epic proportions
at times with Hollywood Stars and Government officials
filling the ranks on both sides. The two teams have
struggled to bring their opponents to the very brink of
defeat only to endure a heroic effort by the other team to
gain back the lost ground. Both teams are bone tired, but
neither will give up. Maybe we hunters should just stop
the game.The Humane Society of
the United States. They’re not just pet and farm animal
advocates, they dislike hunters, too. From their website,
“ We seek a truly humane society in which animals are
respected for their intrinsic value, and where the
human-animal bond is strong”. (I had to look up
“intrinsic” so don’t feel bad.) I read the definition
about five times and then read Roget’s Thesaurus for the
synonyms of this word and decided it meant: they like
animals because they’re cute and we can own them to enjoy
their cuteness for our own gratification. Of course
Brittany Spears (one of their show biz star supporters)
could have given us the definition, too. OK, I can see
this. They look at a pig and see a pet, we look at the
same pig and smell pork chops.
HSUS (Humane Society of the United
States) has decided that baiting bears to hunt them on
Federal lands is wrong. Please read the story at:
http://www.hsus.org/ace/16258 There are two pages to
read. Just the way the story is written is inflammatory
and the best quote is from former Minnesota Governor,
Jesse Ventura where he talks of feeding “Yogi” for five
days and then shooting him in the back. “That ain’t sport.
That’s assassination”. In so many words, Jesse has accused
bear hunters using bait as the murders of Yogi the bear, a
cute cartoon character. I’ve seen bears in the wild and
none of them reminded me of Yogi, or Boo Boo, for that
matter.
This is the opposing team’s latest drive
to pull hunters over the line in the dirt and win. Now,
there is one fun piece of strategy in playing tug of war.
When one side tires of the game, a disciplined team can
all at once let go of the rope and watch the other team
fall flat on their butts. I think it’s time to let go the
rope and see what happens. Here’s an idea to think on.
Hunters agree to quit baiting bears on
Federal land as long as HSUS takes full responsibility for
any bear problems. In fact, the hunters take it a step
further and totally quit hunting the bears on Federal
land. Well, since we’re just talking about it, how about
if hunters voluntarily stop hunting bears in Michigan
altogether for say about ten years or so? (But only if
HSUS takes responsibility for the outcome) I can see the
legs and shoes in the air from back here.
Now, since our whole team has let go of
the rope, the DNR isn’t responsible for bear problems
either. The U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service might be off the
hook, but you never know whose team they’re on in the
first place. Bottom line is, anyone that had anything to
do with the management of black bears in Michigan, can now
drop the rope. Most of us are on the look out for new
management techniques and this new “intrinsic” method
might teach us something.
All we need from the HSUS is the phone
numbers of their members that will take calls from
farmers, cabin owners, hikers and campers that are tired
of Yogi messing up their lives. And just think of the
benefits to all of us sportsmen from this gesture of
goodwill. We’ll see more bear near roadways just like the
deer are now because there’ll be so many more of them, not
being hunted and all. Why, we’ll be able to find one
behind almost every tree in the woods in a few years and
when we decide to start hunting them again there will be
no need for baiting at all.
I suspect that HSUS would decline the
offer of any such agreement. The fact is they and PETA
(read, vegetarians) will never get along with hunters and
our dealings with Yogi and Bambi. The cow killed for a Big
Mac and the chicken butchered for KFC will never die the
death these folks would be happy with, either.
The battle for hunting baited bears on
Federal land will just have to be another time for us to
tighten the grip on the rope and dig in our heels. But,
wouldn’t it be fun to drop the rope once to see what
happens? |